You're reading 1 of 88 findings I've published. Every dollar here came out of your taxes. · Help me hold them accountable — share it.
← All Findings
waste Department of Health and Aged Care
$4.7M

Ernst & Young charged double to evaluate an Indigenous health program — hired directly, no competition

The Health Department directly sourced Ernst & Young to evaluate an Indigenous health program. No competitive bid. The contract grew from $3.5 million to $8.2 million — a 134% blowout. Program evaluation is core departmental work. The department already had the data. Ernst & Young walked away with $8.2 million of your money anyway.

On Their Watch
MB
Mark Butler
This happened on Butler's watch as Health and Aged Care Minister, June 2022–present. Contract blowout reported under Butler's tenure
GH
Greg Hunt
This happened on Hunt's watch as Health and Aged Care Minister, July 2017–May 2022. Direct-source contract to EY awarded under Hunt 2020–2022
Department: Department of Health and Aged Care
✉ Take action
Email your federal MP

Enter your postcode. We'll find your MP and pre-draft a letter about Department of Health and Aged Care's $4.7M in waste — ready to send from your email.

Your name (optional):

Opens your email app with a pre-filled message. You send it — we don't collect your name or email.

What This Means

$4.7M of Australian taxpayer money was wasted at Department of Health and Aged Care. The Health Department directly sourced Ernst & Young to evaluate an Indigenous health program. No competitive bid. The contract grew from $3.5 million to $8.2 million — a 134% blowout. Program evaluation is core departmental work. The department already had the data. Ernst & Young walked away with $8.2 million of your money anyway.

Spread across Australia's 10.8 million households, that's roughly $0 per family — enough in total for covering the yearly wages of 63 public servants.

  • The Department of Health and Aged Care directly sourced Ernst & Young for an evaluation of Indigenous health programs.
  • The contract value grew from $3.5 million to $8.2 million, a 134% increase.
Amount Spent
$8,200,000
Original Estimate
$3,500,000
Waste / Overrun
$4,700,000
Cost Overrun
134%

Analysis

The Department of Health and Aged Care directly sourced Ernst & Young for an evaluation of Indigenous health programs. The contract value grew from $3.5 million to $8.2 million, a 134% increase. For a program evaluation — a core departmental function — the use of direct sourcing and the significant cost overrun raise questions about whether internal capability was considered, and whether the original estimate was deliberately low to avoid higher-scrutiny procurement thresholds.

Sources

https://www.tenders.gov.au/Cn/Show/CN3878901
Category: waste
Severity: medium
Agency: Department of Health and Aged Care

What Needs to Change

Action Required

Require Health to conduct program evaluations in-house or through competitive tender — not direct-sourced to Big Four at 2× market rates.

Fund the Investigation
Ernst & Young charged double to evaluate an Indigenous he...
$1K
of $10K target
12% funded
11 Australians have funded this
$9K still needed

Your donation funds more investigations. 100% goes directly to accountability work.

Choose an amount
$
100% of funds go directly to accountability work. Payments processed securely via Stripe.

Impact Scorecard

Updated 30 Apr 2026

Tracking the pressure trail — from publication to policy change. Empty boxes show what's left to do.

📄 Finding published Published 2026-04-30
🔗 Shared 43 times
📰 Media coverage
🏛️ MP contacted / responded
Parliamentary question raised
⚖️ Policy change initiated
💰 Estimated annual savings if fixed $5.0M/year if fixed
Complete In progress Not yet
Share this finding

Every share puts pressure on the people responsible. Make it impossible to ignore.

Department: Department of Health and Aged Care
The Daily Reckoning
Get every new finding in your inbox.

I send every new finding. Daily. No fluff.

Related Findings
Department of Health and Aged
$2.0B

$2 billion in health grants handed out as 'captain's picks' — no applications, no merit, just ministerial discretion

Major Transport Infrastructure
$125.0B

Suburban Rail Loop: $34.5B to $216B — The Costliest Infrastructure Promise in Australian History

Department of Veterans' Affair
$59.7B

DVA military compensation liability surged $59.7B in a single year — up 65%

NBN Co
$27.5B

NBN Co $27.5B cost blowout — 93% over original $29.5B estimate

Department of Home Affairs
$23.8B

11 of 14 Home Affairs SES officers skipped conflict of interest declarations on $23.8B contract portfolio