You're reading 1 of 32 findings. Every dollar here came out of your taxes. · Share it — that's how this works.
← All Findings
waste Services Australia / Department of Health and Aged Care
$1.5B

$1.5 billion in medication claims stuck unprocessed — while pharmacists wait and patients are delayed

Services Australia has $1.5 billion in uncertified Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme claims as of June 2024. The agency measures its own performance with metrics that count transferred calls twice. ANAO found the system only "partly effective" and made 7 recommendations, many of which were not acted on.

On Their Watch
MB
Mark Butler
This happened on Butler's watch as Health and Aged Care Minister, June 2022–present. Minister responsible for PBS administration and Services Australia health mandate

What This Means

$1.5B of Australian taxpayer money was wasted at Services Australia / Department of Health and Aged Care. Services Australia has $1.5 billion in uncertified Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme claims as of June 2024. The agency measures its own performance with metrics that count transferred calls twice. ANAO found the system only "partly effective" and made 7 recommendations, many of which were not acted on.

Spread across Australia's 10.8 million households, that's roughly $139 per family — enough in total for funding roughly 13 public hospitals for a full year.

  • Services Australia has $1.5 billion in uncertified Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) claims as of June 2024.
  • Root cause: Services Australia and the Department of Health and Aged Care failed to reach bilateral service agreements defining processing standards and responsibilities.
  • Without agreed standards, neither agency could be held accountable for the backlog.
Amount Spent
$1,500,000,000
Original Estimate
Not specified
Waste / Overrun
$1,500,000,000
AI Confidence
89%

Analysis

Services Australia has $1.5 billion in uncertified Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) claims as of June 2024.

Root cause: Services Australia and the Department of Health and Aged Care failed to reach bilateral service agreements defining processing standards and responsibilities. Without agreed standards, neither agency could be held accountable for the backlog.

Performance metrics manipulation:

- Services Australia counts completed "calls" differently than Health

- Phone calls transferred to another agency are counted as "completed" by Services Australia even though the work wasn't done

- This artificially inflates Services Australia's performance metrics

- Digital processing rejection rate (5.6%) is more than double the phone channel rate (2.3%) — ANAO noted this anomaly without explanation

ANAO made 7 recommendations in the PBS authority system audit. Services Australia's self-assessment of progress on recommendations was described by ANAO as "partly effective" at best.

Impact: $1.5B in pharmacy claims sitting unprocessed means pharmacists are carrying accounts receivable they can't collect, creating cash flow pressure across the pharmacy sector. Patients with complex medication needs face delays and potential gaps in supply.

Sources:

- Medical Republic: https://www.medicalrepublic.com.au/pbs-authority-system-an-unnecessary-brake-on-good-care/115225

- ANAO PBS audit: https://www.anao.gov.au/work/performance-audit/administration-of-the-pharmaceutical-benefits-scheme

Sources

https://www.medicalrepublic.com.au/pbs-authority-system-an-unnecessary-brake-on-good-care/115225https://www.anao.gov.au/work/performance-audit/administration-of-the-pharmaceutical-benefits-scheme
Category: waste
Severity: high
Agency: Services Australia / Department of Health and Aged Care
Share this finding

Every share puts pressure on the people responsible. Make it impossible to ignore.

The Full Reckoning

3 active investigations. 3 completed. 26 in the queue.

Rank Finding Amount Status
1 Up to $6 billion stolen from disabled Australians every year — and the agency admits it had 'no real control' until 2024 $6.0B Active
2 $5 billion in wrong pension payments — 3 years, every quarter a miss $5.0B Active
3 $2.7 billion gap: Australia's navy ships suffering 'catastrophic failures' $2.7B Active
4 $7.8 billion of your taxes paid to consultants who left nothing behind $7.8B Investigated
5 $3.3 billion in dodgy NDIS claims slipped through because nobody was watching $3.3B Investigated
6 CIMIC Donated $540K to Labor, Liberal and Nationals — Collected $3.1B in Government Construction, 41% Without Open Tender $3.1B Investigated
7 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
8 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
9 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
10 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
11 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
12 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
13 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
14 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
15 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
16 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
17 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
18 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
19 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
20 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
21 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
22 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
23 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
24 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
25 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
26 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
27 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
28 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
29 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
30 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
31 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
32 Coming Soon 🔜 Pending
$53.3B total waste identified — and counting $53.3B