You're reading 1 of 88 findings I've published. Every dollar here came out of your taxes. · Help me hold them accountable — share it.
← All Findings
waste Australian Submarine Agency
$12.7M

Your submarine billions funded McKinsey — without a single competing bid

The Australian Submarine Agency paid McKinsey $12.7 million for management advisory services without running a competitive tender. Australia has committed $368 billion over 30+ years to nuclear submarines. The agency overseeing that program can't be bothered to tender a $12.7M advisory contract.

On Their Watch
PC
Pat Conroy
This happened on Conroy's watch as Defence Industry and Capability Delivery Minister, June 2022–present. Minister responsible for Australian Submarine Agency's procurement oversight
✉ Take action
Email your federal MP

Enter your postcode. We'll find your MP and pre-draft a letter about Australian Submarine Agency's $12.7M in waste — ready to send from your email.

Your name (optional):

Opens your email app with a pre-filled message. You send it — we don't collect your name or email.

What This Means

$12.7M of Australian taxpayer money was wasted at Australian Submarine Agency. The Australian Submarine Agency paid McKinsey $12.7 million for management advisory services without running a competitive tender. Australia has committed $368 billion over 30+ years to nuclear submarines. The agency overseeing that program can't be bothered to tender a $12.7M advisory contract.

Spread across Australia's 10.8 million households, that's roughly $1 per family — enough in total for covering the university fees of 423 students.

  • The Australian Submarine Agency paid McKinsey Pacific Rim Inc $12,700,776 for management advisory services (Aug 2024 – Jun 2025) via sole-source procurement.
  • For context, Australia has committed $368 billion over 30+ years to nuclear submarines — the agency overseeing that program was incapable of tendering a $12.7M advisory contract.
  • AusTender contract notice: ATM ID FIN/007/20RFTPhase1.
Amount Spent
$12,700,776
Original Estimate
Not specified
Waste / Overrun
$12,700,776
AI Confidence
91%

Analysis

The Australian Submarine Agency paid McKinsey Pacific Rim Inc $12,700,776 for management advisory services (Aug 2024 – Jun 2025) via sole-source procurement. No competitive tender was run. No alternative quotes were sought. For context, Australia has committed $368 billion over 30+ years to nuclear submarines — the agency overseeing that program was incapable of tendering a $12.7M advisory contract.

AusTender contract notice: ATM ID FIN/007/20RFTPhase1. Procurement method: Direct Sourcing. Supplier: McKinsey Pacific Rim Inc.

Direct sourcing (sole-source) is permitted under Commonwealth Procurement Rules only in specific circumstances — urgency, unique expertise, or where competition would be genuinely impractical. ANAO has consistently found that Commonwealth agencies misuse direct sourcing by default when the circumstances don't meet the threshold. No publicly available explanation has been provided for why the Australian Submarine Agency — with extensive internal capability and access to the Defence procurement panel — could not invite competing bids for general management advisory work.

Sources:

- AusTender: https://www.tenders.gov.au/Search/CnAdvancedSearch?Keyword=Mckinsey

- ANAO procurement reporting: https://www.anao.gov.au/work/information/australian-government-procurement-contract-reporting-2022-update

- Parliamentary testimony: https://www.aph.gov.au/DocumentStore.ashx?id=0732b488-b8ad-4fb3-a539-a1c1da984873

Sources

https://www.tenders.gov.au/Search/CnAdvancedSearch?Keyword=Mckinseyhttps://www.anao.gov.au/work/information/australian-government-procurement-contract-reporting-2022-updatehttps://www.aph.gov.au/DocumentStore.ashx?id=0732b488-b8ad-4fb3-a539-a1c1da984873
Category: waste
Severity: high
Agency: Australian Submarine Agency
Fund This Investigation
Fund the Investigation
Your donation funds more investigations. 100% goes directly to accountability work.
Choose an amount
$
Secure payment via Stripe. 100% funds accountability work.
Share this finding

Every share puts pressure on the people responsible. Make it impossible to ignore.

The Daily Reckoning
Get every new finding in your inbox.

I send every new finding. Daily. No fluff.

Related Findings
Major Transport Infrastructure
$125.0B

Suburban Rail Loop: $34.5B to $216B — The Costliest Infrastructure Promise in Australian History

Department of Veterans' Affair
$59.7B

DVA military compensation liability surged $59.7B in a single year — up 65%

NBN Co
$27.5B

NBN Co $27.5B cost blowout — 93% over original $29.5B estimate

Department of Home Affairs
$23.8B

11 of 14 Home Affairs SES officers skipped conflict of interest declarations on $23.8B contract portfolio

Major Transport Infrastructure
$19.0B

Victorian Big Build: West Gate Tunnel + Metro Tunnel + North East Link — $19B in Combined Overruns